At the East Palo Alto City Council's public hearing on Tuesday, October 20, residents were divided over a plan to rebuild part of the Woodland Park apartments, Peninsula 360 Press reported. Speakers raised the possible displacement of tenants, the loss of rent-stabilized units, the lack of chances to buy an affordable home and the effect on nearby businesses.
Council members asked about tenants' rights to relocation and to return, how many homes would be replaced and of what kind, and the project's financial feasibility, the outlet reported. Then the council put off its decision to November 17 and asked the developer for more information.
What was before the council
The applicant is Woodland Park Property Owner, LLC, care of Sand Hill Property Company. Its West Bayshore-Newell Improvements project covers about 13.2 acres around West Bayshore Road and Newell Road. The site now holds 459 apartments in 21 buildings, and the staff report says all of them are under the city's Rent Stabilization Ordinance.
The plan would end with 766 homes:
- 315 existing apartments substantially renovated, with 8 more added inside the renovated buildings;
- 144 existing apartments demolished and replaced;
- 239 new rental apartments; and
- 60 new for-sale townhomes.
That is 307 net new homes. The council was not asked to approve the project itself. It was asked to decide how the project meets the city's Inclusionary Housing Ordinance, and to choose a rule for some of the replacement units. Both items were first set for October 6; the minutes show that meeting adjourned early and the items were continued to October 20.
The affordable housing question
East Palo Alto's ordinance requires 20 percent of net new homes to be affordable. For this project that comes to about 61 homes, by the staff report's count:
- 49.4 rentals at deeper affordability: 12.35 at 35 percent of area median income, 24.7 at 50 percent and 12.35 at 60 percent (the fraction is paid as a fee); and
- 12 for-sale homes: 6 at 80 percent and 6 at 120 percent of area median income.
A developer may ask to meet the rule another way. The city then raises the requirement by five percentage points, to about 76 homes. The council may approve the alternative only if it finds, on substantial evidence, that it gives as many or more affordable homes at the same or lower incomes, or otherwise a greater public benefit.
The developer proposes instead:
- 124 affordable rentals, open to households earning up to 80 percent of area median income, with rents set at 30 percent of the income of a household at 60 percent, as the state density bonus law provides;
- No affordable for-sale homes; and
- Waivers so the affordable units need not match the market-rate units in size, bedroom count or mix of unit types, or be spread through the development. The staff report says the developer has not said where the units would be.
The staff report describes this plan as submitted in September. The applicant's June statement attached to the packet proposed 57 affordable rentals.
The developer argues that meeting the ordinance as written is financially infeasible, and that without the project many existing units would still need renovation and no new affordable homes would be built. The 124 units also qualify the project for a 46.25 percent state density bonus, up to 249 homes above what zoning allows; the developer plans to use 230.
Staff recommended approval. The staff report says 124 units is 40.4 percent of the net new homes, more than the roughly 76 the alternative route requires, at an average affordability of 60 percent of area median income against the ordinance's 58.6 percent. It also says the plan drops the 35 and 50 percent levels and gives up 12 to 15 affordable for-sale homes, and that "the Applicant has provided no evidence" that leaving them out gives a greater public benefit. Staff based its recommendation on the overall gain in affordable rentals.
The replacement units
State law requires the 144 demolished apartments to be replaced with homes of at least the same total bedrooms. A replacement unit for a household with lower income must be rented at an affordable rent to a household in the same or a lower income group, under a deed restriction of at least 55 years, and permanently where the city's demolition rules require it. Where a household's income is unknown, state law presumes a share of the units were lower income, using federal housing data.
For units shown to have housed households above lower income, the city may choose, and staff asked the council to pick one:
- Option a. Replace each with a unit of equivalent size at an affordable rent for a low-income household, deed-restricted for at least 55 years, and permanently where the city's demolition rules require it; or
- Option b. Replace each with a unit under the city's Rent Stabilization Ordinance, open to households of any income, under a recorded agreement that keeps the ordinance's rent limits.
The developer has not yet provided the incomes of the households in the 144 apartments. Until it shows that specific units housed households above lower income, the staff report says, the deed restriction applies by default. The council did not choose an option on October 20, Peninsula 360 Press reported.
What it leaves out
- The project approval. The project's entitlements, including demolition, go to the Planning Commission, which must grant a conditional use permit to demolish the units.
- Tenant relocation details. State law and the city's tenant protection ordinance require relocation assistance, and the city ordinance gives displaced tenants, regardless of income, a right of first refusal to the replacement housing built on the site, though the inclusionary units follow the inclusionary rules. State law separately gives lower-income households a right of first refusal to a comparable unit. Those terms would be set in the conditions of approval.
- A second Woodland Park project. The same developer's O'Keefe-Manhattan Improvements, a 1,071-home plan that would build 850 homes on 14.73 acres, with 172 affordable rentals proposed, was also on the agenda. Mayor Webster Lincoln recused himself, and without him the council lacked an in-person quorum, so there was no hearing or vote, Peninsula 360 Press reported. It was moved to the same date.
Who it touches
- Tenants. Households in the 144 apartments to be demolished would have to move, with relocation assistance for eligible tenants. The 315 renovated apartments would remain under rent stabilization. The city's local preference policy gives East Palo Alto residents, people who work in the city and people displaced from the city first claim on the affordable units.
- Families hoping to buy. The plan has no affordable for-sale homes among its 60 townhomes.
- Neighborhood businesses. About 1.56 acres of the site is zoned Neighborhood Commercial. The applicant's statement lists a restaurant and a convenience store on the site today. The council asked for the project's effect on commercial space, Peninsula 360 Press reported.
- The city. The project is estimated to generate more than $5.3 million in sewer and storm drain impact fees, plus park, public facility and other fees, at the rates in effect on December 9, 2025.
What happens next
- November 17. The council takes up both Woodland Park items again. Peninsula 360 Press reported that it asked for the information missing from the application, the projected loss of rent-stabilized units, the effect on commercial space and the public benefit of leaving out affordable for-sale homes.
- Household incomes. Staff will ask the developer for the incomes of the households in the 144 apartments before the Planning Commission hearing. That count decides how many replacement units must be deed-restricted.
- Planning Commission. The council's choices become recommended conditions in the project resolution the commission will consider.
How to weigh in
Comments on an agenda item can be emailed to the City Clerk at cityclerk@cityofepa.org, naming the item. At a meeting, speakers can fill out a speaker card in the Council Chambers at 2415 University Avenue, East Palo Alto, or use the raise hand feature on Zoom when public comment is called. The council's November 17 regular meeting begins at 6 p.m., in person on the first floor at 2415 University Avenue and on Zoom. Agendas, packets and video are posted at cityofepa.granicus.com.