Picture the newest manager at a small business: it doesn't draw a paycheck. It's the tablet by the walk-in that builds next week's schedule, flags who clocked in late and ranks who sold the most. Most days it saves the owner hours. Some days it gets a call wrong, and the person on the other end of that call is somebody's neighbor.
California has now drawn a line around that moment. Starting July 1, 2027, workers in California can no longer be disciplined or fired by software alone, whatever the size of the business they work for. Under SB 947, if an automated system drives the decision, a person has to corroborate it, and the worker gets a written notice in the language the business uses every day. Separate laws that take effect January 1, 2027 protect workers from AI tools that try to read their emotions and from monitoring inside workplace bathrooms. Sen. Jerry McNerney, who wrote SB 947, put it plainly the day it was signed: "No worker should ever be fired or disciplined by a robo boss."
We think that line is right. Our chamber's published advocacy policy says that "smart regulation protects consumers and honest businesses from bad actors," and that "the answer is better regulation, not less protection." Good small businesses already work this way. The owner who knows her crew doesn't hand a firing to an app. The competitor who would, or who would surveil workers in a restroom to shave labor costs, shouldn't gain an edge over the employers who play fair.
We also owe our readers and our members two admissions.
First, the cost is real. The employer groups that opposed SB 947 warned of "costly litigation for even the smallest of employers." A five-person shop has no compliance department. It has an owner, a payroll app and a long week. Pretending otherwise helps no one, least of all the workers these laws are meant to protect.
This is already the narrower version. When Gov. Gavin Newsom vetoed last year's bill, SB 7, he faulted its "unfocused notification requirements on any business using even the most innocuous tools." This year's law dropped the requirement to notify workers before a system is put to use, and it centers on the moments that cost someone a paycheck: discipline and firing.
Second, we did not take a position on these bills while they moved through Sacramento. Our policy says that if we won't put our name on the official legislative record, we won't take a position, so we won't claim one now. On the bills that follow, we will be on the record before we argue in print.
What we ask for now is implementation that makes the honest path the easy path.
The Labor Commissioner should publish plain-language guidance, a short checklist for small employers, and model notices in Spanish and the other languages California workplaces use, well before July 1, 2027. The law already requires the notice to be in the language a business uses for routine communications. A model notice is how that requirement reaches the cook, the cashier and the owner of a five-person shop, all reading the same page.
The Labor Commissioner and the California Privacy Protection Agency should give an owner covered by both one set of instructions, not two. SB 947 leaves businesses covered by the state's consumer privacy law subject to that agency's rules on automated decisions as well.
The people who build the scheduling, timekeeping and HR software that small businesses rely on should put the human review step and the notice into their products, and tell their customers in writing whether a tool reads emotions or collects neural data.
And to workers: from July 1, 2027, if software plays the main part in a decision to discipline or fire you, you must get a written notice, and you can ask for a description of the data that was used. Ask for it.
Our chamber has published a plain-language guide with a seven-step checklist for owners and managers. When the state publishes its forms, we will put them in our members' hands in English and Spanish.
McNerney's own line is the right standard: "AI must remain a tool controlled by humans, not the other way around." Software can help a business run. A person should answer for decisions about people. California drew the line in the right place. Now let's make it easy to stand on it.