"We have to know the law is the law and the city has to abide by it," one Morgan Hill resident told San José Spotlight. On Wednesday, October 21, the City Council approved 105 single-family homes on a 15.8-acre site along the west side of DePaul Drive, just south of Cochrane Road and east of the U.S. Highway 101 Cochrane Road exit. The city's General Plan and zoning call it commercial land. The staff report told the council that denying the project would violate state law and the city's 2025 settlement with the developer.
"I think in these cases we have to make the best of a bad situation," Mayor Mark Turner told San José Spotlight. The council approved the project unanimously, the Spotlight reported.
What the council decided
The item was a public hearing (agenda item 9). The staff report, prepared by Senior Planner Tiffany Brown, asked the council to adopt three resolutions:
- certify the project's environmental impact report, approve its mitigation monitoring program, and adopt findings and a statement of overriding considerations for the impacts that cannot be fully mitigated;
- approve a vesting tentative subdivision map that divides the 15.8-acre site into 114 lots, 105 of them for homes; and
- approve a design review permit for 105 detached single-family homes, with interior streets and common open space.
The Planning Commission reviewed the applications on October 13 and recommended approval 7 to 0. A design permit for more than 100 homes is normally the commission's call, but because the environmental report requires a statement of overriding considerations, every permit went to the council for the final decision.
As of October 26 the city had posted the agenda, the packet, a Spanish agenda and the meeting video, but no minutes or adopted resolution numbers. The vote reported here comes from the Spotlight.
Why the city had little choice
The developer, High Street No. Cal. Development Inc., filed a preliminary application on October 10, 2023 as a builder's remedy application. The Spotlight identifies the developer as High Street Residential, a subsidiary of Trammell Crow Company.
The builder's remedy is part of the state's Housing Accountability Act, Government Code section 65589.5(d)(5). When a city's housing element is out of compliance with state law, a qualifying housing project does not have to match the city's General Plan or zoning. The staff report says the council had adopted its housing element before the application came in, but the state Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) had not finished certifying it, and HCD directed the city to process the application. The environmental findings say HCD certified the housing element on November 29, 2023, about seven weeks after the application came in.
The staff report is direct about the alternative: denying a qualifying builder's remedy application would violate the Housing Accountability Act and, for this project, the settlement agreement. "Residential development was not envisioned for this project site," it concludes.
The settlement behind the project
To avoid permitting delay, expense and the uncertainty of litigation, the city and the developer signed a settlement agreement on October 15, 2025. Under it, per the staff report:
- Three parcels. A recorded lot line adjustment split the land into a 7.83-acre parcel at the southwest corner of Cochrane Road and DePaul Drive, a 4.72-acre parcel between the shopping center and the home site, and the 15.8-acre home site. The Spotlight puts the whole site at roughly 28.5 acres.
- The shopping center stays. The 7.83 acres remain commercial, now called the Poppy Ranch shopping center. The Spotlight reports it will be anchored by a Sprouts grocery store.
- Land for affordable homes. The 4.72 acres will be conveyed to the city and earmarked for affordable housing, which may be part of a mixed-use project.
- 105 market-rate homes. The home site does not have to meet the zoning code. The settlement says the developer may use its best efforts to meet the city's objective design standards, and the developer keeps its right to seek concessions and waivers under the state Density Bonus Law.
- Fees in place of affordable units. The developer pays an in-lieu fee of $23.18 per square foot of livable space to satisfy the city's inclusionary housing rules, which call for 15 percent of units to be affordable. The Spotlight put the fee at more than $5.8 million.
- $500,000 more. The developer contributes $500,000 to the city's Housing Fund to help develop the 4.72-acre parcel.
- Stormwater. The project provides about 2.2 acre-feet of stormwater detention, in a basin of roughly 0.43 acres, serving the city's parcel, the new homes, the hospital facility across DePaul Drive and the Cochrane Tech Center industrial project.
What it covers
- The homes. 105 detached, two-story houses, 26 to 30 feet tall, in four plans with three color palettes, from 2,147 to 2,615 square feet, each with a two-car garage and at least 60 square feet of private yard, porch or patio. There are 158 on-street guest spaces, and electric vehicle charging is required as a condition.
- Open space. Two parks totaling 21,344 square feet against a requirement of 14,700: a 0.22-acre dog park and a 0.27-acre park with a lawn, covered picnic area, play areas for children 2 to 5 and 5 to 12, a fitness station and a bike repair station. The site borders the Madrone Channel Trail.
- Access. Two new driveways off DePaul Drive and a new internal street network.
What it leaves out
- Affordable units on site. All 105 homes are market rate. Affordable housing is expected on the separate 4.72-acre parcel, which the settlement earmarks; the record leaves the size and timing of a project there to be determined later.
- Impacts that remain. The environmental report found four significant impacts that mitigation cannot remove, in three areas: farmland (the project's own conversion and its share of cumulative farmland loss), driving and greenhouse gas emissions. The site holds 10.8 acres of Unique Farmland that will be lost; the developer must preserve farmland elsewhere at a 1:1 ratio or pay an in-lieu fee, but that does not create new farmland. The project is estimated to generate 30.47 daily vehicle miles traveled per resident against the city's threshold of 24.64; required trip-reduction programs (a school carpool program, bike share support and a travel behavior program) can cut that by at most 13.6 percent, to 26.32. The same excess driving underlies a related greenhouse gas impact, which mitigation also cannot reduce enough. The resolution before the council adopts a statement of overriding considerations for all four impacts; the adopted resolution had not been posted as of October 26.
Who it touches
- Future residents and buyers. 105 market-rate single-family homes in a city the state asks to plan for 1,037 homes in the 2023 to 2031 cycle. Housing and Economic Mobility Director John Lang told the Spotlight the city is 39 homes short of that goal with more than four years left.
- Retailers and shoppers. The settlement keeps 7.83 acres for the Poppy Ranch shopping center rather than turning the whole site to housing.
- Lower-income households. The settlement earmarks a 4.72-acre site, to be conveyed to the city, and $500,000 toward affordable housing there, and the developer pays an in-lieu fee to satisfy the city's inclusionary rules, but this project includes no affordable units.
- Neighbors and the hospital campus across DePaul Drive. New traffic onto DePaul Drive and shared stormwater detention.
What happens next
- Before the final map. The developer must complete the farmland mitigation (land set aside or an in-lieu fee, plus a surcharge) before the final subdivision map is approved.
- Final map. The final subdivision map must be approved by the City Council before a grading permit is issued.
- Trees and noise. A tree removal permit, with an arborist report, before any protected tree is removed, and replacement trees approved before building or grading permits; an updated noise study when building permits are submitted.
- Before the first home is occupied. The trip-reduction programs must be in place, subject to the City Engineer's approval.
- The affordable housing parcel. Under the conditions of approval, the developer must convey the 4.72 acres to the city within 30 days after final city approval and the end of all appeal deadlines and statutes of limitations. What the city builds there, and when, is to be decided later.
How to weigh in
The council's decision on the homes is made. Future items, including plans for the city's 4.72-acre affordable housing parcel, will appear on council agendas posted at morganhillca.portal.civicclerk.com, in English and Spanish. Written comments go to the City Clerk at ccpubliccomment@morganhill.ca.gov, by hand or mail to the City Clerk, 17575 Peak Avenue, Morgan Hill, CA 95037, or in person at the meeting. The clerk asks for emailed comments by 3:00 p.m. the day before the meeting so the council has time to review them; comments are accepted until noon on meeting day. Meetings can be attended in person, by Zoom or by telephone, with live interpretation. The clerk's office is at (408) 779-7259 and cityclerk@morganhill.ca.gov.