Talk to the Chamber Se habla español
News

San Francisco moves to put the full monthly cost of a rental next to the rent

SFBAYHCC News Desk · Oct 27, 2026

At the Board of Supervisors' Land Use and Transportation Committee on October 5, Supervisor Bilal Mahmood made his case for a rule on rental fees by comparing an apartment to a plane ticket.

"When you buy a plane ticket or a concert ticket, you expect to see the full price before you pay, and California law now largely requires it," Mahmood said, according to Mission Local. "Renting a home is the biggest purchase most people make every month. It deserves at least the same honesty."

The legislation won't fix the city's housing crisis, Mahmood said, according to Mission Local, but it can help tenants make an informed decision. "Tenants deserve clarity, and they deserve to plan for their future without hidden costs waiting around the corner," he said.

On Tuesday, October 20, the full Board took up the ordinance, which Mission Local calls the "No Hidden Rent" act. Mission Local reported the vote as unanimous; the Board's online record had not posted the vote as of this writing.

What the Board decided

The ordinance (File No. 260680) amends the city's Rent Ordinance, Chapter 37 of the Administrative Code. Mahmood introduced it on June 9 with Supervisors Myrna Melgar, Chyanne Chen and Danny Sauter; Supervisors Matt Dorsey and Rafael Mandelman later joined as cosponsors.

On October 5 the committee (Melgar, Chen and Dorsey) amended it and sent it to the full Board with a recommendation, both by 3 to 0 votes, according to the committee minutes. The Board's October 20 agenda put one question on it: "Shall this Ordinance be PASSED ON FIRST READING?" San Francisco ordinances need a second vote, called final passage, at a later Board meeting, and the file now shows the status "Unfinished Business-Final Passage," though its history had not yet posted the October 20 action. The ordinance is not yet law.

What it covers

The ordinance adds a new Section 37.9G and defines a "Total Estimated Monthly Cost": the base rent plus any other lawful fees or charges the landlord requires the tenant to pay, to the landlord or on the landlord's behalf, on an ongoing basis as a condition of the tenancy.

  • Online listings, from January 1, 2027. A listing must clearly disclose any application, screening or similar fees. If it states the rent, it must also show the Total Estimated Monthly Cost in the same size font, next to the rent, and itemize each included fee with its purpose and amount.
  • Leases dated January 1, 2027 or later. The Total Estimated Monthly Cost must appear on the first page, in the same size font and next to the rent wherever the rent appears, with each fee itemized. For a fee that varies month to month, the lease must explain how it is calculated and state the unit's average monthly cost for the prior 12 months.
  • If a listing falls short. If a listing does not disclose the Total Estimated Monthly Cost in substantial compliance, the tenant who rents the unit may end the tenancy at any time during the lease term with written notice. The landlord may not impose a penalty or take money from the security deposit because of that early termination.
  • If a lease falls short. If a lease requires a fee but does not disclose it as required, the tenant gets the same right to leave, and the landlord may not evict for nonpayment of that fee or charge late fees, penalties, interest or similar charges on it.
  • Eviction rules. The ordinance also amends the Rent Ordinance's eviction section so that nonpayment of a fee or charge imposed in violation of the new lease rule "or any other law" is not grounds for eviction. This part has no January 1 start date and takes effect with the ordinance.

The ordinance also deletes provisions of the Rent Ordinance tied to COVID-19 rent relief and a 2001 to 2003 capital improvement rule, which the legislative digest calls "obsolete and not legally operative."

The committee's October 5 amendments specified that charges paid "to or on behalf of the landlord" count, limited the termination right to "during the term of the lease agreement," and added "agreed to in the lease agreement" to the clause saying the ordinance does not bar charges for property damage or lost keys. It also struck a sentence from the ordinance's statement of purpose saying such fees "may even violate the Rent Ordinance."

What it leaves out

  • No cap or ban. The ordinance requires disclosure. It does not limit the amount of any fee, and it says it does not authorize any fee or rent increase that other law prohibits.
  • Tenants still owe lawful fees. A tenant whose lease did not properly disclose a fee cannot be evicted or charged late fees over it, but the text says this "does not relieve a tenant of the obligation to pay" a fee lawfully agreed to in the lease, and the landlord may still recover it.
  • Other charges. The text does not stop landlords from offering existing tenants extra services later, or from charging for damage or lost keys when the law and the lease allow it.
  • No city enforcer. The ordinance names no agency to enforce it and sets no fines. The remedies are the tenant's: the right to leave, and limits on eviction and late fees, "in addition to any other remedies" the law provides. It gives no new duty to the Rent Board or the City Attorney.
  • Listing sites. The listing rule says what an online listing must include. It does not name listing platforms or assign them a separate duty; the remedy runs against the landlord.
  • Existing leases. The lease rule covers leases dated January 1, 2027 or later.

Who it touches

  • Tenants and people looking for housing, who would see one monthly figure beside the advertised rent and gain the remedies above.
  • Landlords and property managers, including small owners and management firms, who would need to rework listings and lease forms before January 1, 2027, and track average monthly costs for any fee that varies.

At the October 5 hearing, speakers including a representative of the Coalition for Better Housing "shared various concerns regarding the ordinance matter," the minutes say. One public commenter argued for eliminating the fees altogether, Mission Local reported.

Mission Local cited an Urban Institute analysis finding that fees for amenities, utilities and trash can raise tenants' total monthly costs by 10 to 30 percent, and reported that rents have risen 26 percent year over year. The ordinance follows a September 10 package from Mayor Daniel Lurie to address what his office called the city's "rent emergency"; the mayor's announcement does not list this ordinance.

What happens next

  • Final passage. A second Board vote, expected at a following regular meeting.
  • The Mayor. Under the ordinance, enactment occurs when the Mayor signs it, returns it unsigned or does not sign it within ten days of receiving it, or the Board overrides a veto.
  • Effective date. The ordinance takes effect on the 31st day after enactment.
  • Start date for the new disclosure rules. The listing and lease rules apply from January 1, 2027.

How to weigh in

The full Board does not take public comment on matters already heard in committee, according to its agenda. Written comments for the record go to the Clerk of the Board at bos@sfgov.org, or by mail to 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, Room 244, San Francisco, CA 94102. The Clerk's office is at (415) 554-5184. Board agendas are posted at sf.gov/sfbos, and the file is on sfgov.legistar.com as File No. 260680.

SFBAYHCC
Join the Bay Area’s business network.
Members attend SFBAYHCC events free and publish under their own name.