Eleven people spoke during public comment on Tuesday, October 6, when the Santa Clara City Council took up its data center item, and more sent written comments, the clerk's draft minutes show. The item ran so long that the council voted to extend the meeting to 12:30 a.m. When it was done, the council voted 7 to 0 to move water and air quality standards for data centers to the front of the line.
One councilmember wanted to go further. "I would like to do a moratorium," Councilmember Kevin Park said at the meeting, San José Spotlight reported. A separate request from Councilmember Karen Hardy, for a staff update on power for large new users with the option of a moratorium on new stand-alone data centers, was next on the agenda but was not reached. "I'm being very strident, but I was frustrated that we couldn't even bring it to a vote," Hardy told the Spotlight. It is on the council's October 20 agenda. Hardy and Park are two of six candidates for mayor on the November 3 ballot (the Santa Clara County ballot).
What the council decided
The council acted on a staff report approved by City Manager Jovan Grogan, written in response to a request from Councilmember Suds Jain for a policy limiting the type and quantity of water data centers use. On a motion by Hardy, seconded by Councilmember Kelly Cox, the council directed staff to:
- Speed up water and air quality standards and bring them forward separately from the rest of the review.
- Return with the full approach, covering eight areas: water standards, siting standards, community benefits, coordinated city review, demand side grid support, innovations in sustainability, health and safety, and life cycle analysis. The last two were added by the council to the six in the staff report. Air quality standards also came from the council; the staff report does not discuss them.
All seven members voted yes: Mayor Lisa M. Gillmor and Councilmembers Raj Chahal, Kelly Cox, Albert Gonzalez, Karen Hardy, Suds Jain and Kevin Park.
The vote adopted no new rule. It set the order of staff's work. Staff had expected the whole review, including community outreach and the council's final decisions, to finish toward the end of 2027. The motion asks for the water and air standards sooner, without setting a date.
What the review covers
The staff report lists what staff will study:
- Water. City Code section 13.15.160 already requires development projects, data centers included, to use recycled water for approved uses where it is available, and new data centers have had to extend the city's recycled water system to their sites at their own expense. Today staff apply that requirement using qualitative factors, because the code sets no numbers. Staff will consider numerical standards for when a project must extend the system, based on distance to existing pipes, the extension's cost compared to the project's cost, and the project's yearly water use. Staff will also look at efficiency standards that favor lower-water cooling.
- Siting. Apart from a 25-foot rear or side yard setback, the city has no distance requirement between data centers and homes. Staff will evaluate one.
- Community benefits. Staff will look for more ways data centers can benefit the city, beyond the taxes and fees they already pay.
- Coordinated review. Staff will look at formally linking the city's planning review with Silicon Valley Power's power allocation, so applicants learn early about land use rules, power availability and timing, water demand and other standards.
- Grid support. Councilmember Jain asked about the state's Demand Side Grid Support program, run by the California Energy Commission, which pays customers to cut load or run backup generation during grid emergencies. Data centers recently became eligible to take part using backup generators. The report says funding for the program was not approved in the most recent legislative session, so its future is uncertain.
- Sustainability. Staff will study ways to reduce reliance on diesel backup generators and to capture data center heat for nearby buildings.
Where things stand
The staff report sets out the numbers behind the review:
- How many. Santa Clara has 56 stand-alone data centers active or under construction and two approved but not yet built. Eight more pipeline projects have completed system impact studies and are part of Silicon Valley Power's planning.
- No new power requests since 2023. Silicon Valley Power, the city-owned utility, has not accepted applications for new data centers since 2023. In a November 7, 2023, memo to developers, the utility said entitled and under-construction projects had reserved all the new capacity from a planned high-voltage transmission line and the utility's own system expansion. The report says key projects are expected between 2028 and 2030, with about $450 million or more in utility infrastructure work under way.
- Size. The report says no data center in the city has an electric load of 100 megawatts or more, far smaller than the campuses of 500 megawatts to 4 gigawatts proposed elsewhere in the country.
- Water. Data centers account for about 6% of the city's drinking water use and about 26% of its recycled water use. More than half are connected to recycled water.
- Revenue. Staff estimate data centers contributed $35.2 million to the city's general fund in fiscal year 2025/26, about 9% of its resources, through the utility's transfer to the general fund, property tax and sales and use tax. Since 2019 new data centers have paid $3.9 million in affordable housing fees.
- Rules today. Since the 2024 zoning code, a stand-alone data center needs a conditional use permit from the Planning Commission, with appeals to the council, and an architectural review permit. They are conditionally permitted in the LORD, Light Industrial and Heavy Industrial districts and, under 2025 rules, on part of the Related Santa Clara site; only smaller ancillary data centers are allowed in the HORD district. The city's Climate Action Plan requires new data centers approved from December 2022 on to run on 100% carbon-neutral energy, with offsets as needed.
What it leaves out
- No pause. Nothing adopted on October 6 stops a data center project. Hardy's request, which includes the option of a moratorium on new stand-alone data centers, was deferred to October 20.
- No numbers yet. No water limit, air standard or separation distance has been written. Each would come back to the council as its own policy or ordinance, and the report says some may need their own environmental review.
- No cost estimate. The report says developing the approach costs only staff time. Any new regulation would get its own fiscal analysis.
Who it touches
- Data center developers and owners, especially the eight pipeline projects and any future applicant, who could face numerical recycled water requirements, cooling efficiency standards, separation distances and a more formal link between planning approval and power allocation.
- Contractors and trades that build recycled water extensions, cooling systems and backup power for these projects.
- Owners of industrial land in the districts where data centers are allowed, since siting standards would shape what can be built near homes.
- Neighbors of data centers. The report says feedback during reviews of recent data center proposals, particularly about noise and visual impacts, is why the city will keep evaluating siting standards, including separation from homes.
- Silicon Valley Power customers. The report says load development fees and rates are set so all users pay their proportional share, and that the utility's residential rates are among the lowest in California.
What happens next
- October 20. Two requests from Hardy, deferred from October 6, are on the council agenda: one asks staff to report within 30 days on entitlement and power allocation for new large electrical loads, including data centers, with the option of a moratorium on new stand-alone data centers; the other asks the council to discuss a policy barring the city from signing nondisclosure agreements with stand-alone data centers. Under the council's request policy, the vote at this stage is on whether, and when, to put an item on a future agenda.
- Water and air standards. Staff will bring these forward ahead of the rest of the review. No date has been set.
- The full review. Staff's estimate for finishing the comprehensive approach, with community engagement and council decisions, has been toward the end of 2027.
How to weigh in
The October 20 meeting is in the Council Chambers at City Hall, 1500 Warburton Avenue, and on Zoom; the special meeting starts at 5:30 p.m. and Hardy's two requests are on the 7:00 p.m. regular meeting. Written comments can go through the eComment tab on the city's agenda calendar at santaclara.legistar.com, which closes 15 minutes before the meeting, or by email to clerk@santaclaraca.gov by noon on the meeting day, with the agenda item number in the subject line. Written comments are not read aloud. Questions go to the City Clerk's Office at (408) 615-2220.