Think of the people who walk into a county courthouse on a weekday morning: a tenant answering an eviction case, a small business owner in small claims court, a witness under subpoena, a mother asking for a restraining order, a friend who came along to translate. The Legislature found this year that some of them may stay away for fear of a civil arrest in or near the courthouse. A new state law, SB 873, starts on January 1, 2027, to change that.
What the law does
SB 873, by Sen. Eloise Gómez Reyes and Sen. Thomas J. Umberg (Chapter 753, Statutes of 2026), rewrites Civil Code section 43.54. Starting January 1, 2027:
- No civil arrest for lawful business at court. A person may not be subject to a civil arrest while present at a courthouse for any lawful activity, or while traveling to or from one. The law presumes that someone going to, coming from or present at a courthouse is there for a lawful reason.
- The courthouse includes its surroundings. "Courthouse" covers the court facilities, the sidewalks, parkways and streets around them, and any public way within 1,000 feet.
- Lawful activity is broad. It includes attending or taking part in court proceedings and clerk's office business, working at the courthouse, and accompanying or helping someone who is there, such as a spouse or parent, children in their care, interpreters, translators, health care aides and case managers.
- A judicial warrant is the exception. The rule does not apply to an arrest made under a valid judicial warrant.
- What counts as a civil arrest. Taking someone into custody, or saying you intend to, for an alleged violation of civil law. Immigration enforcement, the Assembly's analysis notes, largely involves civil arrests and detentions.
The law covers California's state courts, not federal ones. Its definition of a courthouse rests on the state law for superior court (trial court) facilities, and its list of court proceedings also names the Courts of Appeal and the Supreme Court. Federal immigration courts are not covered.
Enforcement and reporting
- Damages. An arrest that breaks the rule counts as false arrest or false imprisonment if the arresting person knew or reasonably should have known that the person was going to, at or coming from court for a lawful activity. Anyone who violates the law, or helps, is liable for actual damages plus $10,000 in statutory damages, and a person who wins a suit to enforce the law can recover court costs and reasonable attorney's fees. Courts and court staff acting lawfully to keep order are exempt.
- Court orders. A judge may issue orders to protect the privilege.
- Questions at the door. When court security staff know that a law enforcement officer has entered a courthouse in an official capacity, they must ask the officer to identify themselves and state the purpose and intended enforcement action, and ask for a copy of a valid judicial warrant. If staff know that the person named in the warrant has a lawyer, they must ask the officer to let the lawyer review it. Staff must ask; the law does not direct them to stop an officer.
- A yearly count. The Judicial Council must publish an annual report, by county, of the civil arrests that courts report to it under a court rule (Rule 10.440), which covers arrests in court facilities.
Why the Legislature acted
"Discouraging people from coming to court makes our community less safe," Reyes said in her statement to the Legislature. The Senate Judiciary Committee's analysis cited reports of at least two dozen people detained on courthouse grounds in Stanislaus, Glenn, Los Angeles and Fresno counties.
The law's own findings say that victims, witnesses and other court users who fear civil arrest may be reluctant to attend hearings, seek protective orders or comply with subpoenas, and that such arrests cause missed court dates and delays and make it harder for courts to obtain testimony and evidence. The California Public Defenders Association, a co-sponsor, told the Legislature that agents wait "on courthouse steps, in parking lots, and at building exits," which it called a gap in the law now in force.
Who was on the record
The Senate passed SB 873 by 29 to 7 on May 26, the Assembly by 58 to 17 on August 25, and the Senate approved the final version 30 to 10 on August 28. Gov. Gavin Newsom signed it on September 29.
Its supporters in the final Senate analysis included public defenders, legal aid groups (among them the Law Foundation of Silicon Valley), the Judicial Council of California, Los Angeles County, tenant and disability rights organizations, Oakland Privacy and the Consumer Attorneys of California. The California State Sheriffs' Association and the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department opposed it. The sheriffs' association warned that the bill "places sheriffs' officials in a position of unavoidable conflict between state and federal law," and said the wider courthouse definition, reaching public ways within 1,000 feet, made the prohibition "overly broad." The San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department predicted a legal challenge over the law's reach to federal officers; the Assembly Judiciary Committee's analysis expected it to hold up.
The Assembly Appropriations Committee estimated costs "of an unknown, but potentially significant amount" to the state Department of Justice, to advise courts and the public, investigate complaints and litigate violations. The estimate, repeated in the final floor analyses, was made before the Assembly removed a provision that would have let the Attorney General sue over violations.
What you can know now
- If you have a court date, the protection starts January 1, 2027. It covers the trip to and from court as well as the time inside. Until then, existing law already bars civil arrests inside a courthouse for people attending a proceeding or doing legal business there, and the Assembly Judiciary Committee's analysis says an older common-law privilege likely protects people traveling to and from court as well.
- A judicial warrant is different. The rule does not stop an arrest under a warrant signed by a judge, or an arrest on a criminal charge.
- Talk to a lawyer before you decide not to go. Missing court can hurt your case. A legal aid group, or a public defender if you face a criminal charge, can explain the risks before you decide.
- Employers: California's SB 294 already requires employers to let workers name an emergency contact, to be notified if they are arrested or detained at work. Our News Desk guide explains it.
This is a summary of the law, not legal advice. If a court rules on a challenge to the law, we will update this page.