Talk to the Chamber Se habla español
News

Self-checkout rules: what the state tried, and what San José is studying

SFBAYHCC News Desk · Oct 27, 2026

At the front of a big grocery store, one employee may be watching a bank of self-checkout machines, unlocking a case of razor blades, keeping an eye out for theft and helping a shopper whose scale will not read the bananas. The union that sponsored a state bill on self-checkout told the Legislature that workers "are expected to monitor anywhere from four to ten machines on their own." The grocers who opposed it say most shoplifters walk out the front door, not through the self-checkout lane.

San José is now deciding whether to write rules for that front of the store. Here is where things stand.

San José: a staff report by January

On October 7, the City Council's Rules and Open Government Committee took up a memo from Councilmembers Domingo Candelas and David Cohen. It asked the City Manager to review self-checkout safety and staffing standards for grocery and drug stores, drawing on ordinances in other cities, and to return with policy options before the Council sets its priorities for the 2027-2028 fiscal year. It also asked staff to explore working with Santa Clara County's Office of Labor Standards Enforcement.

The committee voted 3 to 1, with Vice Mayor Pam Foley against and Councilmember Rosemary Kamei absent, to approve a staff workload analysis and directed the City Manager's Office of Administration, Policy and Intergovernmental Relations to prepare an informational memo for the Council by January 2027. The staff plan covers a review of state bills and local ordinances, plus input from city departments on retailer impacts, retail theft trends (from the Police Department) and current local labor standards. Original data collection, formal outreach beyond city departments and the county, drafting ordinance language and designing an enforcement program are outside its scope for now.

Foley is termed out at the end of the year. District 9 voters choose her successor on November 3, between Genny Altwer and Gordon Chester, so the Council that receives the memo in January will seat a new District 9 member (the Santa Clara County ballot).

"Our goal is not to eliminate self-checkout, but to ensure that any standards we consider are practical, balanced and responsive to the needs of workers, customers and businesses," Candelas told San José Spotlight.

What other cities require

The memo points to ordinances adopted in Long Beach (August 2025), Costa Mesa (February 2026) and Santa Ana (May 2026), and says Anaheim and West Hollywood have considered similar rules. It lists the kinds of provisions they include:

  • a staffed checkout lane open whenever self-checkout is open;
  • a limit of 15 items at self-checkout;
  • at least one dedicated employee for every three self-checkout stations;
  • no self-checkout for alcohol, tobacco or other age-restricted items (state law has barred alcohol sales at self-checkout since 2012), or for locked-case goods and items with theft-deterrent devices;
  • self-checkout stations placed where employees can see them;
  • signs telling customers and workers their rights, and enforcement that includes a period to fix a violation, a right for workers and customers to sue, penalties and protection from retaliation.

What the state tried

Sen. Lola Smallwood-Cuevas has carried the idea in Sacramento twice, the second time with two San José legislators, Sen. Dave Cortese and Assembly Member Ash Kalra, among her coauthors. Her SB 1446 of 2024, which was broader, died in the Assembly Rules Committee. Her SB 442 of 2025, as last amended, would have let a covered store offer self-checkout only if:

  • at least one staffed manual checkout lane was open whenever self-checkout was;
  • the store had a policy limiting self-checkout to 15 items, with signs saying so;
  • customers could not use self-checkout for items that require an ID, such as alcohol and tobacco, or items with theft-deterrent devices that an employee must remove;
  • the employee watching self-checkout was not assigned other duties at the same time.

It would also have required stores to include self-checkout in the hazard analysis of their injury and illness prevention programs and to give workers and their unions 60 days' written notice before adding it. The Labor Commissioner could have fined a store $1,000 per violation per day, up to $200,000.

Which stores it reached. Only grocery stores over 15,000 square feet, superstores over 75,000 square feet and drugstore chains with 75 or more locations in California. Grocery stores of 15,000 square feet or less and pharmacy owners with fewer than 75 California locations were outside it. The grocery line was drawn by floor space, not ownership, so a large independent grocer was covered.

What happened. The Senate passed SB 442 by 26 to 10 on June 2, 2025, and the Assembly Labor and Employment Committee approved it 5 to 0 on June 25. It then went to the suspense file of the Assembly Appropriations Committee, whose staff estimated annual enforcement costs to the Department of Industrial Relations "in the low millions of dollars," likely partly offset by penalty revenue. Its last action was on August 29, 2025. It dies with the session on November 30.

Who was on the record. Labor unions led the support, with the United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council as a co-sponsor, joined by advocacy groups. The California Grocers Association, the California Retailers Association and other business groups opposed it or asked for amendments. No city or county registered a position.

What each side says

Smallwood-Cuevas made the workers' case in her statement to the Assembly Labor and Employment Committee: "While tools like self-checkout are utilized to decrease labor costs, ultimately, it is the worker and consumer who pays the biggest price when our stores are understaffed."

The California Grocers Association, writing with a statewide business group, called SB 442's 15-item limit "arbitrary" and objected to treating self-checkout as a "work hazard" in stores' injury and illness prevention programs. In San José, Kent Streeb, a director of Safeway's Northern California division, told the committee that "grocery stores operate on thin margins of about 1.7%" and that a local ordinance "would at least double operating costs for self-checkout (machines) at our 12 remaining stores in San Jose." Nate Rose of the California Grocers Association pointed Spotlight to an August memo from Long Beach city staff, which found that 10 of 13 affected businesses reduced or closed self-checkout lanes after that city's rule took effect. The same memo reports more staff at checkout areas and longer waits, records labor representatives' view that the rule brought safer working conditions and more manageable workloads, and says it is not a full evaluation of worker, customer or public safety effects.

The California Grocers Association also told the city, in a letter filed for the committee's hearing, that recent contracts between the United Food and Commercial Workers and grocery companies in California, including in the Bay Area, already set self-checkout terms: a full-service lane open from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. whenever self-checkout is open, a dedicated employee for each self-checkout bank (who may help nearby when no more than one customer is using it), and signs asking customers to keep self-checkout orders to about 15 items. Terms vary by contract. The Lucky contract posted by UFCW Local 5, which runs to 2028, assigns one employee to monitor up to eight self-checkout machines for at least eight hours a day and requires a manual lane whenever self-checkout is available.

Jim Araby of United Food and Commercial Workers Local 5 told Spotlight that the grocers' objections are about cutting labor costs and shifting checkout work onto customers.

What the numbers show

Reported shoplifting in California rose 13.8 percent in 2024 and was 47.5 percent above its 2019 level, the Public Policy Institute of California found, even as overall property crime fell. The institute notes that part of the rise may reflect more complete reporting. Preliminary figures for 2025, compiled by staff of the state's Committee on Revision of the Penal Code from police agencies covering about half of Californians, show reported shoplifting down 9.5 percent from 2024. Statewide figures do not say where in a store theft happens; the San José staff report is set to include Police Department input on retail theft trends.

How to weigh in

The informational memo goes to the full Council by January 2027, ahead of its priority-setting for the 2027-2028 fiscal year. Workers, store owners and shoppers can write to their councilmember and to the Council now, while staff do the research, or speak during public comment when the Council sets its priorities. Store owners: if self-checkout matters to your business, this is the window to say how.

SFBAYHCC
Join the Bay Area’s business network.
Members attend SFBAYHCC events free and publish under their own name.