Talk to the Chamber Se habla español
Perspective

Before San José decides on self-checkout rules, start at the front of the store

Evodio Walle · Oct 27, 2026

Think of the front of a big San José grocery store at the end of a workday. A line at the one open register. A bank of self-checkout machines, one of them blinking for help. A locked case of razor blades, a shopper waiting for a key. One employee is trying to be in four places at once.

Everyone in that picture wants the same thing. The cashier wants to be safe and not alone. The grocer wants fewer losses and shoppers who come back. The shopper wants to pay and go home. The question in front of San José is what, if anything, gets all three.

Where San José stands

On October 7, the City Council's Rules and Open Government Committee voted 3 to 1 to have city staff prepare a report on self-checkout standards for grocery and drug stores by January 2027, before the Council sets its priorities for the next fiscal year. Councilmembers Domingo Candelas and David Cohen brought the idea, pointing to ordinances in Long Beach, Costa Mesa and Santa Ana: a staffed lane whenever self-checkout is open, a 15-item limit, one employee for every three machines, and no self-checkout for alcohol, tobacco or locked-case goods.

The sides arrived far apart. Kent Streeb of Safeway told the committee that such an ordinance "would at least double operating costs for self-checkout (machines)" at the chain's 12 remaining San José stores. The union that sponsored the state bill told the Legislature that workers "are expected to monitor anywhere from four to ten machines on their own." In Sacramento, Sen. Lola Smallwood-Cuevas put the workers' case in one line: "it is the worker and consumer who pays the biggest price when our stores are understaffed." Her bill, SB 442, passed the Senate and then stalled in the Assembly. It will not become law this session.

Candelas has set the right standard. "Our goal is not to eliminate self-checkout, but to ensure that any standards we consider are practical, balanced and responsive to the needs of workers, customers and businesses," he told San José Spotlight. Workers, customers and businesses: that is the whole store. January gives the city time to meet that standard.

Five questions the January report should answer

  1. What do contracts already require? In a letter filed for the committee's hearing, the grocers' trade association wrote that recent contracts with the grocery workers' union, including in the Bay Area, already require a full-service lane from 8 a.m. to 7 p.m. whenever self-checkout is open, a dedicated employee for each self-checkout bank and signs asking for about 15 items. Terms vary: the Lucky contract posted by the union assigns one monitor to up to eight machines, where the ordinances elsewhere require one employee for every three. The report should say where a city rule would go beyond the contracts, which stores have no such contract, and how many people work in them.
  2. How big is the store? SB 442 reached only grocery stores over 15,000 square feet, superstores and drugstore chains with 75 or more California locations. The corner market and the family pharmacy were outside it, though the grocery line was drawn by floor space, not ownership, so a large independent grocer was in. Any San José rule should be at least that careful about who it reaches.
  3. Where does theft happen here? Reported shoplifting in California rose 13.8 percent in 2024, the Public Policy Institute of California found, though some of that may be more complete reporting, and preliminary figures for 2025 compiled for a state commission show it down about 9.5 percent. Workers' unions say understaffed self-checkout areas draw shoplifters. Grocers say most shoplifters walk out the front door. The report should say whether San José police data can show what statewide figures cannot.
  4. What happened in Long Beach? Its rule took effect in September 2025. An August memo from Long Beach city staff, which the grocers' association cites, found that 10 of 13 affected businesses reduced or closed self-checkout lanes. Store managers reported more staff at the checkouts and longer waits; labor representatives reported safer, more manageable work. The memo did not measure theft. San José should ask Long Beach for those numbers.
  5. Who needs a staffed lane? The councilmembers' memo is right that self-checkout does not work equally for seniors, people with disabilities or anyone with a full cart. A staffed lane is a service to customers, not only a staffing number.

Why a business voice belongs here

A grocery store anchors a commercial street. When it locks the shelves, closes lanes or closes its doors, the bakery and the pharmacy next to it lose foot traffic too. When one cashier is left alone with a bank of machines, a theft becomes her problem and a lost customer becomes everyone's. The owner who staffs the front of the store well should not be undercut by the one who does not, and the neighborhood market should not inherit a rule written for a superstore.

What we ask

  • The City of San José: make the January report answer these five questions, and bring workers, independent grocers and chain stores to the same table before anyone drafts an ordinance. The plan the committee approved leaves out new data collection and formal outreach; the Council can widen it.
  • Grocers and the union: share the contract terms and the theft data with the city, so any rule builds on what you have already agreed to.
  • Our members: if you run a market or a pharmacy in San José, tell us how self-checkout works in your store. We will gather what you tell us, send it to the city and publish what we learn.

We took no position on SB 442, and we are not for or against an ordinance that has not been written. We are asking the city to get the facts first, and to decide with the people who work the front of the store.

SFBAYHCC
Join the Bay Area’s business network.
Members attend SFBAYHCC events free and publish under their own name.