Talk to the Chamber Se habla español
Perspective

What enforcement costs Main Street

Evodio Walle · Oct 27, 2026

On the morning of Thursday, October 8, immigration agents arrested a parent in a Richmond neighborhood near Nystrom Elementary School. That day the West Contra Costa Unified School District asked principals to put staff outside at drop-off and pickup, Richmondside reported. The district says the parent's children are not its students. Even so, it told ABC7 that fewer students came to class the next day than before other three-day weekends.

A child kept home can mean a parent kept home: from a shift, a job site, a lunch rush. An enforcement surge lands first on families. Then it travels down the commercial street.

What the numbers show

In July, ICE made 890 arrests in the California part of its San Francisco "area of responsibility," the state north of Bakersfield, according to KQED's analysis of agency records posted by the Deportation Data Project at UC Berkeley and UCLA. That was the most in any month since January 2025. In the city of San Francisco, Mission Local counted about 189 July arrests and found that arrests in the city had not risen above 2025 levels. Immigration lawyers told KQED that people are often summoned to ICE check-ins on short notice. Check-ins are typically required of people who lack a visa but have some provisional permission to remain in the country.

The Department of Homeland Security disputes the data. A spokesperson told KQED the project "relies on information releases that have not been reviewed, audited or given context."

What a surge costs a corridor

We found no published measure of the cost to Bay Area corridors. A national survey shows how far the worry reaches: in October 2025, 59 percent of Latino adults told the Pew Research Center they had seen or heard of immigration arrests or raids in their area in recent months, and 8 percent said they were going grocery shopping less often than usual because they might be questioned about their legal status. The closest measure of what that costs a corridor is from Los Angeles County. A July study by the UCLA Latino Policy and Politics Institute and Inclusive Action for the City tracked 989 businesses within half a mile of nine sites of the June 2025 enforcement operations there. Within two weeks, they had an estimated 46,000 fewer customer visits and about $3.16 million in lost revenue. The authors say that understates the loss, since street vendors, food trucks and home-based businesses are not counted, and the decline was not confined to majority-Latino neighborhoods.

The researchers also surveyed 75 Latino entrepreneurs: 59 percent reported sales down by more than half, 68 percent closed for a time or cut hours, and 51 percent said staff missed work out of fear. The authors caution that the owners were not a random sample, so those shares describe the participants, not every business in the county.

"The loss of customers disrupted businesses across sectors and formats, regardless of the owner's immigration status," said Amada Armenta, the institute's director and a co-author.

Those are Los Angeles numbers, not ours. Here, the chain would likely run the same way. When customers stay home, the owner loses the sale, and cooks, cashiers and drivers of every status lose hours. The landlord waits on rent, the supplier on an order, the city on sales tax. Customers, citizens among them, lose the shop they count on.

Certainty is a business issue

Every business plans around rules. An owner schedules shifts or signs a lease expecting them to hold next month. We believe the law should be enforced, with due process and in ways people can predict. Commerce runs on that certainty.

Under SB 873, by Sen. Eloise Gómez Reyes and Sen. Thomas J. Umberg, starting January 1, 2027, no one may be subject to civil arrest while at a California courthouse for any lawful activity, or on the way to or from one, without a valid judicial warrant. The courthouse includes public ways within 1,000 feet. Immigration enforcement, the Assembly's analysis notes, largely involves civil arrests. Contract disputes, small claims and evictions all depend on people showing up. The California State Sheriffs' Association opposed it, saying it places sheriffs' officials "in a position of unavoidable conflict between state and federal law."

For employers, the basic federal duty has not changed: every U.S. employer must complete Form I-9 for every person it hires, citizens included, and keep it on file for inspection. California adds its own: under SB 294, also by Sen. Reyes, employers owe each worker a yearly written notice of workplace rights and must let workers name an emergency contact to be told if they are arrested or detained at work. The Labor Commissioner posts free templates in Spanish and other languages.

We took no position on either bill; we cite them for what they do. Our News Desk explainer has SB 873's full record.

What we ask

  • Bay Area cities: measure what a surge costs your corridors, using local sales-tax and business-survey data, and have bridge loans, rent deferral and small-business emergency grants ready before the next one.
  • Officials at every level: enforcement that follows due process and that businesses can plan around.
  • Employers: give your workers the notice the law requires. Workers: ask for it, and name an emergency contact.

Our chamber will publish a plain-language guide for employers, Spanish edition first, that points to the official sources. It will not replace a lawyer's advice.

Neighbors are customers, and customers are neighbors. Residents and businesses can ask their cities, together, to count the cost of an emptied corridor and be ready for it.

SFBAYHCC
Join the Bay Area’s business network.
Members attend SFBAYHCC events free and publish under their own name.